Tag Archives: advertising technology

Marketing Technology that Powers $42.3B in E-Commerce

Quick link:  Download report here.
This was our second year releasing the Marketing Technology Holiday E-Commerce report.  It’s no Lumascape, but it’s damn interesting.

It started as a simple project for me to understand which top e-commerce players were using different Marketing Technologies.  This year, we included trending information from last year’s report.

Here is a link to the new 2012 report (PDF), and a link to the old 2011 report (PDF).  The actual data set that it is derived from can be downloaded here for your own analysis.

I owe a big thank you to my friends at Evidon for providing me this information as Ghostery powers much of it.

AdExchanger was kind enough to write up the report late yesterday and hopefully you had a chance to read it.

Here are my takeaways:

1.  Social.  100% of the 20 surveyed sites were using social plug-ins or another form of social connectivity.  While social is the grouping, this shows the power of “earned” media; or at least the potential power of “earned” media.

2.  Audience.  I’ve been harping on this for years now.  We need to understand audiences in marketing.  Not just online, but in store too.  We’re seeing these top e-commerce sites learning about their audiences by deploying different marketing technologies that could help shape audience experiences, products, customer service, etc.

3.  Mixpanel.  I was surprised to see them in the top 10 marketing technologies utilized.  They are an analytics platform for the desktop and mobile web.    Impressive to see them breaking into the top 10.

4.  Slow decline of the ad networks.  Not the death as many folks have predicted but 51% less ad networks year over year.  Google AdWords was the top ad network (no surprise).

Again, the report isn’t perfect due to classification of companies but it’s directionally accurate.  I look forward to hearing your thoughts!

Cookies, The President, and Ad Tech

There is lots of chatter in the government and the digital advertising industry around privacy and cookies.  You can do a simple Google search and get all the details about self regulation vs. government reform.  I even created a Slideshare document on this back in October 2010.

I wanted to write this post to document something:  if the government steps in to intervene in the privacy and cookie war in the digital advertising industry, lets look at what President Obama used to help win his re-election.

Obama has at least 30 providers of marketing & advertising technology working for him.  Romney as of 12:19PM ET today (11/7/12) has 18 trackers.  This Obama screengrab was taken at 11:55pm ET last night on his official homepage.  Ghostery provided the insight on the right of the screenshot and we can see many cookie-enabled technologies.

Next time you hear about the government coming down hard on cookies & privacy, remember this post.

(This post is not supposed to be a political ding in favor of one party over the other.  I’m one of the least vocally political people in the USA.  It is supposed to provide insight into cookie use for political candidates, in this case, the President Obama.)

 

One Buying Platform for All Media

Back in June 2011, I wrote a post titled, The 87.5% Category According to Luma – Lots of Acquisitions.  The purpose of the article was to highlight that ad serving systems for online/digital media had a high propensity to be acquired or realize a significant exit.  87.5% of all ad servers on the chart had gone through an exit.  Not bad.

Over the last week of December, I spent some time at home and caught up on my favorite blogs and online content in between playing with my two kids.  In doing this, I spent time reading a December 20th post on AdExchanger by Google’s VP of Display, Neal Mohan.  While I’ve personally never met Neal, I have a lot of respect for what he’s doing at Google.  He has a great quote that I couldn’t agree with more:

We also know that advertisers and agencies ideally don’t want a separate buying platform for each type of media — they want a way to buy across all formats, and in 2012 I think they’ll get it. Real-time bidding (and by extension audience buying) has proven to be a transformative technology for buying desktop display — on our exchange, it currently accounts for 60 percent of all transactions. In 2012, we’ll start getting into that ballpark for mobile and video as well.

If you recall, when I wrote the 87.5% article, I highlighted an area in particular stands out to me as a killer opportunity:

If I personally was to start a company tomorrow, I’d probably create the next 3rd party ad serving system built for the future of all media (able to serve site-direct placements, social media and RTB) and include the opportunity for biddable, rich media, video, and full reporting & analytics.  I believe no ad serving system delivers superior reporting and analytics so this is an area that I’d specifically make sure I’d nail.

I think this is an area for massive innovation because the vision that the industry hasn’t recognized the full vision for the future… I believe that all media will be served, tracked, and optimized across all channels.  Television, print, radio, and out of home will all in some way or another be served, tracked and optimized.  This obviously cannot happen overnight as there are quite a few barriers and obstacles to go thru, but the opportunity is huge.  There is a reason why 87.5% of the companies in the ad serving segment have been acquired.

It looks like Neal and I are thinking the same thing and if any of you entrepreneurs are as well, I’d love to meet you.  This is an area that we are searching to invest in at kbs+ Ventures.  You can contact me here.

Marketing Technology behind $35 billion in holiday 2011 ecommerce sales

Ever wonder who is the marketing technology behind the $35 billion dollars in e-commerce sales this holiday season? If you are an agency, wall street analyst, marketer, optimizer or any other player in the digital media ecosystem, you probably want to read below.

I always tell my team at The Media Kitchen that you can learn a lot from what other companies are doing; the good, the bad, and the ugly… so study them.  On the web, it’s relatively easy to study companies and their respective infrastructure as the source code of competitors is only 1 click away.

I teamed up with my friends over at Evidon who own the Ghostery product and had them send me a data dump of 3rd party tags that were placed on 20 e-commerce sites (list below).  Note, the data I have is fairly reliable but not perfect, so I may have missed a partner here or there.  However, I do have over 150+ partners who had tags down on these 20 e-commerce destinations, so I feel I have a directionally accurate view of who was part of the marketing technology ecosystem for Holiday 2011.

Sites I tracked were Best Buy, CouponCabin, Sports Authority, LL Bean, Gap, Dicks Sporting Goods, Bed Bath & Beyond, SVPPLY, DSW.com, Modells, Zappos, Old Navy, Disney, Target, Walmart, Gilt, Sears, Amazon, NewEgg, and Piperlime.

I counted a total of 413 partner tags/pixels placed across these 20 sites (note, I only went to 1-2 pages per site and assumed tags would be similar across most pages).

Executive Summary (full report can be downloaded here)

  • Best Buy, CouponCabin, and Sports Authority properties contained 43% of all tags placed.  The top 10 of the 20 sites accounted for 85% of all tags placed.  I am actually surprised that Amazon didn’t fall into the top 3, but again, Ghostery told me they only had 3 tags down on their pages (Turn, DoubleClick, Google Analytics).
  • The top 3 tags placed across all 20 sites were Google Analytics, Omniture, and DoubleClick.  No real surprise here.
  • The biggest surprise IMHO is that Google+1 outranks Facebook and Twitter as social plug-ins that are embedded across these ecommerce publishers.
  • The DSPs are in-line with the recent Forrestor report so I didn’t find anything crazy in those numbers.
  • Google Analytics has 70% coverage across these 20 e-commerce sites.  Imagine the data that Google could/is collecting.  Just saying.

In order to digest this 1000+ cell data dump, I created a schematic whereas I broke down the product (such as Tag Management) and took the top companies and their % composition the 20 e-commerce destinations.  The link to the excel sheet is at the bottom of this post.

Web Analytics software:  Google Analytics (70%), Omniture (60%), Foresee (40%), Webtrends (15%), Yahoo Analytics (15%), Coremetrics (10%)

3rd Party Ad Serving:  DoubleClick (55%), Microsoft Atlas (25%), ValueClick MediaPlex (35%), MediaMind (5%)

Tag Management:  BrightTag (20%), TagMan (5%)

DSP:  AppNexus AdNexus (30%), Turn (25%), MediaMath (20%), Invite Media (20%),  AdNetik (10%), X+1 (10%), Lucid (5%), DataXu (5%), Rocket Fuel (5%)

Exchange:  Right Media (35%), AdBrite (15%), OpenX (10%)

SSP:  PubMatic (50%), Rubicon (25%), Admeld (10%)

Social Plug-Ins:  Google +1 (45%), Facebook (40%), Twitter (15%), AddThis (15%)

Site Optimization:  Omniture (60%), Monetate (20%), RichRelevance (20%), Visual Website Optimizer (15%)

I believe the Omniture & DoubleClick tag data above is a bit misleading because those are grandiose tags that can do many different things and without the right context, they could be categorized incorrectly.  I tried my best.

Conclusion

Google dominates pretty much up and down the marketing technology stack. I still think they should buy Adobe to become the monopolistic dominant player (to get Omniture), but I don’t believe the government will ever allow that.

I was actually surprised that Omniture didn’t have even higher composition of the 20 ecommerce players.

I couldn’t tease out DoubleClick AdX from their other tags so that’s why they weren’t included in the Exchange part.

And of course, since I work, play, and invest in the marketing technology ecosystem, I’m conflicted up the wazoo with many of the companies mentioned in this post as well, as, the data in the chart linked below.  I have done my best to tease out bias.  Please proceed with caution but honestly, I don’t think you need to.  Contact me if you are interested in discussing.

Thought you might find all of this data interesting.  I have included my chart here in case you want to download it and play with it.  The full report I put together is located herePlease remember to give proper attribution if you use it.

I’m curious to look at this data in 2012 and compare it to 2011 (I don’t have historicals).  I’m sure we’ll see some interesting changes.

Happy holidays.

Darren Herman is the Chief Digital Media Officer of The Media Kitchen (part of kbs+) and is President of kbs+ Ventures which is an early stage marketing technology institutional investment arm of the agency.  His tweets can be found at @dherman76 and blogging here at http://www.darrenherman.com

The 87.5% Category According to Luma – Lots of Acquisitions

I’ve spent a bunch of time with ad servers in my life.  It all started when I was installing phpAdsNew for my brother‘s website, Exotic Car Network, creating ad zones across Student.com in OpenAdStream, a web property that about 7 of us ran in the late 90s, working on the team to create a self-service ad buying platform for eBay, creating a proprietary ad server for the in-game advertising marketplace called Radial, founded MDC‘s trading desk practice using BidManager and TerminalOne, and finally, using DART, Atlas, and MediaMind at the agency that I’m currently at.  Now looking back at it, I’ve centered much of my career around served and tracked media.

So as you can see from above, I spend quite a bit of time with media technologies.

I believe they will play a large role in the future of advertising and I will continue to play in this field over the coming decades.  There’s been an increased amount of coverage in this space which was once reserved for the back floors of the premier industry showcase, AdTech.  Terry Kawaja is bringing some light humor and some fantastic charts, John Ebbert is creating a mini-media empire (well, not an empire), Brian Morrissey is resurging an old newsletter back to the top, and there’s been a handful of acquisitions lately including Admeld (Google) and MediaMind (DG Fast Channel) totaling close to $1 billion.

According to the display Lumascape, the only category with 87.5% of companies acquired, yes, 87.5%,  is the ad server category.  Crazy when you think about it.  Atlas, DART, MediaMind, Pictela, PointRoll, MediaPlex, etc have all been acquired.  There are some independents in the market today such as OpenX and insurgent AdZerk, but the majority have already been acquired.  I predict that the category is still ripe for innovation and will continue to see many new players enter the space.  I was a personal shareholder of MediaMind and it was one of the larger positions I’ve held.

I continue to think that the best 3rd party ad server is exactly that – a 3rd party ad server that is not biased towards any media.  Almost exactly a year ago, I wrote a piece titled, “Insurgent:  How to take down Atlas and DART.”  I continue to dislike Google’s positioning in the marketplace as overnight they theoretically could shut off access to their inventory for non-DART users (could, not should), Microsoft has an ad serving system built in the 1990s and still feels like it, and this left an opening for a major ad serving player to come in with an independent stance, thus MediaMind gained traction.  I love this stance as mentioned above and it needs to continue.

A few days ago, I wrote a post about attribution and the growing advertising operations line-item.  If you haven’t read it, you should.

If I personally was to start a company tomorrow, I’d probably create the next 3rd party ad serving system built for the future of all media (able to serve site-direct placements, social media and RTB) and include the opportunity for biddable, rich media, video, and full reporting & analytics.  I believe no ad serving system delivers superior reporting and analytics so this is an area that I’d specifically make sure I’d nail.

I think this is an area for massive innovation because the vision that the industry hasn’t recognized the full vision for the future… I believe that all media will be served, tracked, and optimized across all channels.  Television, print, radio, and out of home will all in some way or another be served, tracked and optimized.  This obviously cannot happen overnight as there are quite a few barriers and obstacles to go thru, but the opportunity is huge.  There is a reason why 87.5% of the companies in the ad serving segment have been acquired.

Note, I don’t think you need to start from scratch.  If you could raise some money, you can start by acquiring several of the pieces.  There are quite a few DSPs who could use an exit right now.   There are even some large independent ad servers who would be interested.  A roll-up strategy would be interesting and something that could come together nicely.

One of the bigger parts here is that you need to service the advertiser (or marketer).  This needs to be written on all company walls.   Mandated thru corporate handbooks.  This is similar to how SSP’s service the publisher.  You cannot be all things to everyone and when this happens, decisions sometimes become very tough to make as you try to please too many constituents.  Think about all the decisions Google (and Admeld) had to make about where to flow it’s ad dollars – to Google-run sites or it’s 3rd party network of sites.  Stick to one core area of focus and innovate within it.

This area gets continually dinged because there isn’t a ton of money to be made.  $0.04 average CPM and 200 billion monthly impressions net out to about $8MM in monthly ad serving fees (~$100MM/yr).  That’s a nice company but think of how many are larger.  If you create a robust reporting & analytics infrastructure, ad verification, workflow solutions, etc – you can charge a premium.  I believe you can.  Create a premium bundle of services to execute within the Ad Ops space, and sell them as one package.  There are buyers.

The space is only going to heat up further.  Continued innovation, a lot more media technology thinking, and investment will raise the industry forward.  I know I want to be a part of it!

2010 Post Highlights

I’ve written a bunch of posts on this blog in 2010.   Not all are my favorites but below, I’ve highlighted the ones that are.  You can find a list of all-time favorite posts here ranging back to 2006.

Organizational Behavior

Data, Marketing Technology

Twitter & Social

Investing

Enhanced by Zemanta